Kurtenbach: Why it’s looking unlikely that Giancarlo Stanton lands with the Giants

MIAMI, FL - OCTOBER 01: Giancarlo Stanton #27 of the Miami Marlins hits during a game against the Atlanta Braves at Marlins Park on October 1, 2017 in Miami, Florida. (Photo by Mike Ehrmann/Getty Images)
The San Francisco Giants should incorporate electrical power this offseason. In a league in which the long fly ball is becoming more important every calendar year, the Giants’ MLB-worst 128 homers final season simply ought to be improved on this winter.

So it should come as no surprise which the Giants are enthusiastic about trading for Marlins slugger Giancarlo Stanton, who strike 59 homers very last season and it has one hundred fifty homers in his previous 4 seasons (497 games).

The Marlins, who have been recently sold to an possession team that includes Derek Jeter, appear hellbent on restocking a depleted farm system and slashing payroll to $90 million this offseason – the most direct way to do satisfy both of those of those people wishes should be to trade Stanton, who signed a 13-year, $325-million cope with the Marlins in November 2014 (he has an opt-out once the 2020 season).

Stanton might be costly, although the Giants have the money to carry him in as well as the motivation to provide the Marlins what they have to obtain a offer performed.

But it surely looks ever more unlikely that Stanton will land in San Francisco this offseason.

There are conflicting accounts all over the place – there’s quite a bit to parse from baseball’s GM conferences – but two stories from reliable sources have put a serious damper on any Stanton-to-the-Giants hopes.

The first arrived from the famous Peter Gammons, who noted on his site that Stanton is not enthusiastic about a deal that might mail him to St. Louis, Boston, or San Francisco.

Stanton provides a comprehensive no-trade clause, and though he’s open to being traded, he, by all accounts, is poised to generally be judicious during this process. (And, to be specific, Gammons reported that all those 3 groups would have to “sell” Stanton on becoming a member of them as “they’re not metropolitan areas that fascinate him for different reasons”.)

It makes sense why Stanton would not be “fascinated” by San Francisco – which has practically nothing to carry out using the metropolis alone, which, of course, is gorgeous.

When you have been destined to be traded, would you need to visit a group that missing ninety eight games previous year, has what could well be described as a lame-duck coaching staff, and could well be 50 % a season away from an extended and unpleasant rebuild? Would you desire to perform in a very ballpark that is definitely 23 p.c more durable to strike a home run in than another stadium in baseball? Would you be prepared to consider exactly what is effectively a 13 p.c shell out slice on top of all of that? (Florida does not have a state cash flow tax.)

The Bay Area may be an enchanted place to are living and work, but it really makes complete sense why Stanton would not be interested inside the Giants.

“I never need to rebuild … I have missing for seven years,” Stanton advised FanRag Sports in September.

Nevertheless, the Giants stood a chance of convincing him to take a chance on San Francisco if his options had been confined.

It really is nice in this article plus the Giants have won 3 World Collection this 10 years.

Although the second report back to occur outside of the GM meetings is the one that would pour h2o all over that flickering “maybe”:

For each MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand, the “Dodgers are indeed during the mix for Giancarlo Stanton”.

Noting that “being while in the mix” is often a considerably cry from being in trade negotiations – when the Dodgers are severe about landing Stanton, then Giants followers can terminate their pre-orders on these black and orange Stanton jerseys.

Stanton can be a Southern California child who grew up a Dodgers enthusiastthere is little question that he’d be interested in taking part in in La for considered one of the best groups in baseball.

Incorporate during the simple fact that the Dodgers have maybe as much as $50 million to spend this offseason and among the best farm methods in baseball from which to offer the Marlins, and it’s not easy to see this match not being made.

When there is any major traction on these negotiations, it wouldn’t be in the slightest degree surprising if Stanton, leveraging his no-trade clause, tried to force the deal through.

Simply put, in the event the Dodgers are interested in actively playing ball, the Giants can’t perform around the identical subject as them.

Philadelphia, St. Louis, possibly even Boston (who has a bottom-third farm system, much like the Giants, though the Red Sox’s is markedly much better) – the Giants, with their monetary clout, can compete with those groups for Stanton.

However the Yankees or Dodgers – two groups that are profitable now, have seemingly unlimited cash, and boast great farm techniques – are unassailable.

We’ll see from the coming times how really serious the Dodgers are in landing Stanton. We’ll find out if the Yankees get in about the bidding or if a mystery staff arrives into participate in, but when the sector is, in fact, becoming crowded, then the Giants’ long shot hopes of landing baseball’s reigning home operate king have become even longer.