Father tries to take back guilty plea in rape, murder of teen daughter


Just after abruptly admitting through his loss of life penalty demo that he was responsible of forty nine heinous crimes, like drugging, sexually abusing and killing his 14-year-old daughter, Mark Mesiti needs to consider it again.

Mesiti, 49, has asked a Modesto choose to let him withdraw his responsible plea within the long-running circumstance, which started more than the usual decade ago whenever a Santa Clara County choose awarded him custody of his young ones despite his lengthy felony file.

The loved ones of sufferer Alycia Allen-Mesiti was horrified following learning Friday afternoon of Mesiti’s change of coronary heart from the Stanislaus County District Attorney’s Business. Prosecutors there could not be attained for comment.

“Mark is disgusting,” stated Alycia’s great-aunt, San Jose resident Roberta Fitzpatrick. “He employs the system to torture us.”

Mesiti’s sudden decision previously this thirty day period to plead responsible six months following the jury had been picked out spared Fitzpatrick and Alycia’s mom a few more months of listening to excruciating testimony.

Just after sedating his daughter, Mesiti experienced photographed or videotaped more about forty sexual assaults against her. He also admitted to felony sexual assault counts against two other women. One was eight years previous; another was 16 and 17. Under an buy by Stanislaus County Judge Dawna Reeves, just the jurors had been shown the pictures. But the viewers, which include Fitzgpatrick, was aware of the testimony.

Now, as opposed to sentencing Reeves to daily life without parole, Reeves will have to choose regardless of whether to permit the case to commence to trial before a new jury.

Commonly, a defendant who regrets pleading responsible or no contest does not routinely obtain a hearing to create his case. But because Mesiti represented himself at trial, under California law the judge must give him an opportunity to point out good cause for withdrawing the plea. Good result in could involve arguing that he wasn’t aware of each of the repercussions of pleading guilty.

Even though which may be a stretch because the consequences ended up evidently that he could well be sentenced to lifetime without parole, the truth that it really is a loss of life penalty demo where the stakes are extremely high makes it challenging to predict the result. Mesiti could argue that he realized he may well in some way obtain a greater end result than lifestyle in jail by having his possibilities at trial.

Alycia was killed in 2006, lower than a yr just after Mesiti was awarded custody of her and her brother by Santa Clara County Exceptional Courtroom Judge Vincent J. Chiarello.

According to court docket documents, the choose was conscious at the time that inside the seven yrs before being awarded custody, Mesiti had been convicted of state and federal prices, which include financial institution fraud and drunken driving. He also was charged with domestic violence and purchased to show up at anger-management lessons after pleading guilty to a lesser demand. After failing to adjust to court orders to attend drug- and alcohol-treatment programs, he landed in prison for violating probation.

Alycia’s mother, Roberta Allen, was described by a courtroom investigator being an unfit mother who had battled with depression. Having said that, in an investigation by this news organization after Alycia’s body was found in 2009, Roberta Allen explained her years-long legal struggle as “very angled towards Mark. I couldn’t afford a lawyer. He had a person.”

Chiarello, that is at present assigned to listening to legal instances in Palo Alto, has declined to touch upon the case considering that cadaver-sniffing dogs found Alycia’s entire body 8 yrs back buried in the unkempt garden of her father’s previous home during the Central Valley neighborhood of Ceres.

An autopsy determined she experienced died of acute drug intoxication, in line with the Stanislaus County District Attorney’s Office environment. Tests with the human body showed the presence of opiates, morphine, amphetamine, methamphetamine, benzodiazepines, diazepam, methadone, and anti-depressants.

According to a statement released by Stanislaus County prosecutors, Mesiti experienced hundreds of thousands of illustrations or photos involving child pornography. Hundreds of people illustrations or photos showed Mesiti’s daughter being sexually assaulted even though she was definitely unconscious. Films also showed the defendant setting up a concealed camera inside the bedroom of the 8-year-old lady who lived while in the apartment with him and his girlfriend in La County for the time. Other video clips and images showed a 16-year-old female Mesiti had befriended being sexually assaulted.

For the time of his arrest, he was operating a methamphetamine laboratory in La.